eBook - ePub
Museum Provision and Professionalism
Gaynor Kavanagh, Gaynor Kavanagh
This is a test
Partager le livre
- 376 pages
- English
- ePUB (adapté aux mobiles)
- Disponible sur iOS et Android
eBook - ePub
Museum Provision and Professionalism
Gaynor Kavanagh, Gaynor Kavanagh
DĂ©tails du livre
Aperçu du livre
Table des matiĂšres
Citations
Ă propos de ce livre
Museums are public places where objects, images and memories are kept and shared. They exist in infinite variety and contradiction. They can be places of great excitement and great boredom, sharply insightful and hopelessly bland. Museums are anything that the political climate and the imagination allows them to be. No two museums are the same.
The papers which make up this volume give ample evidence of the variety of views that exist about museums. They also demonstrate that museums and museum professionals are moving forward with energy and conviction. This volume will be invaluable to students and museum professionals and will provoke them to consider museum provision and professionalism in all their forms.
Foire aux questions
Comment puis-je résilier mon abonnement ?
Il vous suffit de vous rendre dans la section compte dans paramĂštres et de cliquer sur « RĂ©silier lâabonnement ». Câest aussi simple que cela ! Une fois que vous aurez rĂ©siliĂ© votre abonnement, il restera actif pour le reste de la pĂ©riode pour laquelle vous avez payĂ©. DĂ©couvrez-en plus ici.
Puis-je / comment puis-je télécharger des livres ?
Pour le moment, tous nos livres en format ePub adaptĂ©s aux mobiles peuvent ĂȘtre tĂ©lĂ©chargĂ©s via lâapplication. La plupart de nos PDF sont Ă©galement disponibles en tĂ©lĂ©chargement et les autres seront tĂ©lĂ©chargeables trĂšs prochainement. DĂ©couvrez-en plus ici.
Quelle est la différence entre les formules tarifaires ?
Les deux abonnements vous donnent un accĂšs complet Ă la bibliothĂšque et Ă toutes les fonctionnalitĂ©s de Perlego. Les seules diffĂ©rences sont les tarifs ainsi que la pĂ©riode dâabonnement : avec lâabonnement annuel, vous Ă©conomiserez environ 30 % par rapport Ă 12 mois dâabonnement mensuel.
Quâest-ce que Perlego ?
Nous sommes un service dâabonnement Ă des ouvrages universitaires en ligne, oĂč vous pouvez accĂ©der Ă toute une bibliothĂšque pour un prix infĂ©rieur Ă celui dâun seul livre par mois. Avec plus dâun million de livres sur plus de 1 000 sujets, nous avons ce quâil vous faut ! DĂ©couvrez-en plus ici.
Prenez-vous en charge la synthÚse vocale ?
Recherchez le symbole Ăcouter sur votre prochain livre pour voir si vous pouvez lâĂ©couter. Lâoutil Ăcouter lit le texte Ă haute voix pour vous, en surlignant le passage qui est en cours de lecture. Vous pouvez le mettre sur pause, lâaccĂ©lĂ©rer ou le ralentir. DĂ©couvrez-en plus ici.
Est-ce que Museum Provision and Professionalism est un PDF/ePUB en ligne ?
Oui, vous pouvez accĂ©der Ă Museum Provision and Professionalism par Gaynor Kavanagh, Gaynor Kavanagh en format PDF et/ou ePUB ainsi quâĂ dâautres livres populaires dans Commerce et Administration des musĂ©es. Nous disposons de plus dâun million dâouvrages Ă dĂ©couvrir dans notre catalogue.
Informations
Part 1
The museum: some definitions
1
Some definitions of âmuseumâ
Timothy Ambrose and Crispin Paine
It is important to know exactly what we mean when we use the word âmuseumâ. But, even so, definitions do not come easily and most need some qualification. The concept of a âmuseumâ is in a continuous state of development. It is modified by the politics of the museumâs situation, the content of its collections and the audiences it aims to serve. However, a number of what might be called âworking definitionsâ are in existence and these guide our thinking by reminding us of the fundamental features that distinguish a museum from other types of institutions and practices.
THE ICOM DEFINITION
âA non-profit-making, permanent institution, in the service of society and its development, and open to the public, which acquires, conserves, researches, communicates and exhibits, for the purposes of study, education and enjoyment, material evidence of man and his environment.â
THE MUSEUMS ASSOCIATION (UNITED KINGDOM) DEFINITION
âA museum is an institution which collects, documents, preserves, exhibits and interprets material evidence and associated information for the public benefit.â
âInstitutionâ implies a formalised establishment which has a long-term purpose. âCollectsâ embraces all means of acquisition. âDocumentsâ emphasises the need to maintain records. âPreservesâ includes all aspects of conservation and security. âExhibitsâ confirms the expectation of visitors that they will be able to see at least a representative selection of the objects in the collection. âInterpretsâ is taken to cover such diverse fields as display, education, research and publication. âMaterialâ indicates something that is tangible, while âEvidenceâ guarantees its authenticity as the âreal thingâ. âAssociated informationâ represents the knowledge which prevents a museum object being merely a curio, and also includes all records relating to its past history, acquisition and subsequent usage. âFor the public benefitâ is deliberately open ended and is intended to reflect the current thinking, both within our profession and outside it, that museums are the servants of society.
THE AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF MUSEUMS DEFINITION
âA non-profit permanent, established institution, not existing primarily for the purpose of conducting temporary exhibitions, exempt from federal and state income taxes, open to the public and administered in the public interest, for the purpose of conserving and preserving, studying, interpreting, assembling, and exhibiting to the public for its instruction and enjoyment objects and specimens of educational and cultural value, including artistic, scientific (whether animate or inanimate), historical and technological material. Museums thus defined shall include botanical gardens, zoological parks, aquaria, planetaria, historical societies, and historic houses and sites which meet the requirements set forth in the preceding sentence.â
This paper first appeared in T.Ambrose and C.Paine (eds) (1993) Museum Basics, London: Routledge, p.8.
2
The Museums Charter
Museums Association
Most formal definitions of âmuseumsâ stress the functional aspects of museum provision. Few are invested with any form of ideal or vision: the âdoingâ predominates. Such definitions help us define the activities of museums yet rarely their perceived social, cultural or political purposes. Individual museums have redressed this by devising âmission statementsâ, that is, short summaries of their ultimate goals. In these, philosophy dominates over function, dreaming over doing, thinking over reacting. This is an important task. Arguably, there has to be space in museum work for vision and hope; moreover there has to be opportunity for the contemplation of horizons broader than the next acquisition or the reorganization of the stores.
In 1991, the Museums Association published its Museums Charter to act as a reminder of the factors essential for âthe creation of a modern and dynamic museum sceneâ. This was aimed principally at opinion formers and politicians, but is an indicator of the concern currently held by museum professionals in the UK.
Ultimately we as citizens must determine the value we place upon one of the essential hallmarks of a civilized country: an educated and informed society. A strong and dynamic museum culture that is accessible and of benefit to all members of society is integral to this achievement. This principle should underpin national and local government policies for museums.
Museum provision should remain varied and flexible, allowing for the differing needs of every type of museum, whether independent, local authority maintained, co-operative venture, national or regional. However, the present patchwork system of provision is highly unsatisfactory. It fails to provide adequate support for museums and does not allow them to realize the full potential of their collections. A national duty of stewardship is implicit in the publicâs right of access to the national heritage.
The Museums Association considers the following eight factors essential for the creation of a modern and dynamic museum scene.
Public right to museums
Museum collections are a fundamental national resource to which everyone has a right of access. Central and local government should take appropriate measures to ensure that no sector is prevented from enjoying this right.
Education
Museum collections represent unparalleled opportunities for education, recreation and inspiration. The full learning potential of all museums must be recognized and realized.
Protection of the heritage
Museums should be able to save the heritage. This requires realistic funding and an appropriate export legislation regime.
Safeguarding of collections
All museum collections should have unambiguous legal status, with clearly defined responsibilities for their management.
Caring for collections
Museums should care for their collections to a high standard and should have policies for their management and development.
Autonomy
All museum services should enjoy a high degree of autonomy, enabling rational priorities to be set for scarce finances.
Resources
All types of museums should be underpinned by a system of policy and funding, sufficient at least to maintain or enhance existing standards.
Training
Adequate funding and commitment should be forthcoming from central government and museum governing bodies to ensure training of a progressive and structured nature for all staff and volunteers.
The Museums Charter was first published by the Museums Association, London, in 1991.
Part 2
Thinking about museums
3
The museum as a staging ground for symbolic action
Sheldon Annis
There can be little doubt that museums are complex institutions and that there is no simple way of understanding them. In fact, they are better understood as places which give rise to a variety of experiences. The unexpected is the norm, and the best laid plans of curators, education officers and marketing experts can be creatively altered by the imagination and expectations of the museum visitor. Those who visit museums and indeed all those in whose name museum developments take place add a wonderfully subversive element to museums in any society. The joy of museums is their capacity to be places where people explore something of themselves, although this does not necessarily come about in the way the museum itself may intend.
Sheldon Annis has captured these often contradictory aspects of museums and by so doing touches on their extraordinary capacity and potential.
In recent years there has been much scholarly literature written on the concept of the âsymbolâ. A host of related termsâsign, signal, semiotic, emblem, icon, signans, signatumâhave spread into disciplines, as diverse as anthropology, art history, linguistics, folklore, geography and literary criticism. The Concise Oxford Dictionary defines symbol as âa thing regarded by general consent as naturally typifying or representing or recalling something by possession of analogous qualities or by association in fact or thoughtâ. In other words: something which stands for something else, but ambiguously and with disparate meanings. What a symbol is not is an algebraic equation, where S=something else. Rather, symbols are âmultivocalâ and âpolyvalentââthat is, they speak with many meanings and in many combinations. They change with backdrop and grow with use. And it is precisely their fluidity, rather than their capacity to represent directly, that makes them central to human thought and action.
A museum is a kind of cultural warehouse. It is a place for things taken out of their natural context to be stored, reclassified and exhibited.
When objects become exhibits, they necessarily take on new meanings: they are transformed. The warehouse, among its other uses, serves as a linking place. The object-symbols twist in meaning between two worlds, the world of their origin and the world of significance created by display.
In presenting them, museums assure visitors that objects are valid and illustrative of larger frames of meaning. Museum curators, after all, are culturally designated to be communicators. By selecting and framing objects, they bestow legitimacy on them. Implicitly, the unseen curator tells the audience: this is the real thing, take this seriously.
Yet just as there is a gap between the world of the object and the world of the museum; so too, there is a gap between the world of the museum and the world of the viewer. Even though the visitor is assured that museum objects are praiseworthy, personal meaning remains personal. It is something that exists largely independently of the designerâs message. For the visitor, it is something to be found or created.
How does the visitor make his way towards a personalized warehouse of symbols? And what, if anything, does the capacity to associate objects with meaning have to do with the growing popularity and success of museums throughout the world?
The answer to these questions, I believe, lies in the museumâs character as an expressive medium. That, in turn, is a function of its physical nature. As a kind of text that projects symbols and is meant to be read, interpreted, or experienced, a museum has its own set of qualities. Unlike a film, a book, or a painting, the museumâs symbols are approachable from many directions (literally) and in an almost infinite number of sequences and combinations. The meaning of a visitorâs experience depends on choice of movement among stationary symbols.
Compare the museum with a play. In a theatrical performance the audience remains stationary while the symbols on stage move (âactâ). The pacing and delivery of the message is in the hands of the theatrical group, subject to the receptivities and sensibilities of the audience. In the museum, the situation is reversed. The âtheatre managerâ sets up a sprawling stage with motionless objectsymbols, and the audience is responsible for its own âpacingâ. In a fashion, each member writes his own script. The visitor travels in, about, and through a set of symbols, seeking to tie them together with associations and meaningsâas if each visitor were author and star in his own play.
A museum designer normally conceives an exhibition as a dramatic whole. Many exhibitsâ evolution, the story of aluminium, the rise of Etruscan stonewareâare plotted as micro-dramas. However, as anyone who has ever visited a museum knows, oneâs own thoughts and choreography rarely follow the script suggested by the museum designer. The private script need not preserve the didactic public seriousness, much less the conceptual wholeness. The visitorâs script is a more complex affair: disconnected, improvised and usually fun.
In thinking about how visitors distil meaning from the museumâs terrain and the symbols in their paths, it is useful to imagine âscriptsâ, or symbolic engagements occurring simultaneously at more than one level. These levels of object-viewer interaction can be thought of as âspacesâ. Three such spacesâdream space, pragmatic space, and cognitive spaceâare discussed below.
DREAM SPACE
Dream space is a field of subrational image formation. In the museum, it is the field of interaction between suggesting/affecting objects and the viewerâs subrational consciousness.
Consider, for a moment, museum objects detached from their labels and the order that museum design has given them. As such, the museum is transformed into a container for patterns, shapes, colours and sounds. The visitor moves forward, and against this abstract backdrop appears a changing panorama of suggestive thingsâthings stripped of their primary use and natural context but cleverly laid out to suggest other times and places. The viewerâs mind and eye subrationally seize upon certain objects that jolt memory or recognition and provoke internal associations of fantasy, desire and anxiety. That subset of objects marked off by the mind and eye delimits dream space.
Dream space is akin to the space created by expressionist painting. Take, for example, the Chagall etching, The Man and the Sentry. Here we see objects that are disassociated from real world relationships. Shape and line suggest rather than represent. The disembodied objects become symbols, or at least triggers. A manâs face (or a womanâs?) perches atop a horse (a smoking horse, a 20 SHELDON ANNIS smoking house?) from which marches a sentry (the same man?, guarding what?). A horse, house, and sentry in place of a torso; they rest on pulpy (male?) legs that are seated on a chair.
There is contextual disorder, but it is precisely the disorder that makes the work provocative. The viewer finds a dual pleasure: first, the testing for emotional resonancy with the artist, checking oneâs own response to suggestion (is there a horse and sentry within me?); and, second, the intellectual process of synthesizing, second-guessing, and interpreting the artist and his symbols (was there a horse and sentry within Chagall?).
The symbols of expressionist painting are flat and frozen. The viewer can only stand before the surface, projecting himself onto it and testing his vision against someone elseâs dream space vision. The symbolic landscape of the museum, on the other hand, is three- rather than two-dimensional. The visitor can move into, through and past. He can slow down images, speed them up, or hold them steady. The museum is experienced as a flickering of and among symbols. The eyes, the brain, and the feet collaborate to give velocity and direction to the third dimension. In museum dream space there is a flow of images and meaningsâhighly personal, sometimes lulling, sometimes surprising, more or less conscious: âI like thisâ, âI donât like thisâ, âI donât care about thatâ, âI know thisâ, etc.
PRAGMATIC SPACE
Pragmatic space is the field of activity in which physical presence rather than objects have meaning. The visitor himself is likely to be the main symbol in pragmatic space. The channels and paths he chooses may have meanings largely independent of the contents of the museum.
Take, for example, the holiday-maker as museum-goer. A trip to the Louvre can be a symbol for a trip to Paris, which in turn has personal significance in light of fifty previous weeks of routine and money management. The museum is experienced more as a conquest than a visit. Having heroically touched the four corners in two hours, the traveller leaves satisfied (if exhausted). The museum hangs like a trophy from his beltâmaterial evidence, purchased in the museum shop, tucked securely under his arm. To have been there is a statement.
The opportunity presented by museum space allows us to indulge our self-imagery: here I am, connoisseur. Here I am, meditating. But most activity in pragmatic space indulges our social natures. An observer who sits at the museum entrance will notice that visitors from out of town are likely to make museum visits in groups of social equals (husbands/ wives, friends, tour group members); but locals almost always go in groups of social unequals (parent/child, teacher/learner, guide/guided). Social inequality generates a certain tension. Roles are brought into focus, and then brought to life by talk and movement. As diads and triads of social unequals move thro...